The Mercury: Talking Point: A proposal to build hundreds of 270m-high wind turbines on Robbins Island should be worrying - Bob Brown

Comment, July 8, 2019

When Singapore’s Fragrance Group of developers raised the height of the proposed Harmony Hotel building in central Hobart from 120 metres to 210 metres the populace, quite reasonably, had conniptions.

Hobart’s tallest building remains the modest 19-storey Wrest Point Casino tower, just 73 metres high, and many Hobartians want to keep it that way. None of the buildings in Hobart’s CBD is 60 metres tall.

So spare a thought for Tasmania’s Robbins Island. It is about to get UPC Robbins Island Pty Ltd’s 120 towers, each 160 metres high — more than twice the height of the NAB building in Collins St — with ailerons of 110 metres, which will have their tips spinning to the dizzying apex of 270 metres. There will be 200 such towers if the developer gets the Hodgman Government’s tick of approval — and who would doubt that?

Mariners will see this hairbrush of tall towers from 50km out to sea and elevated landlubbers will see it, like it or not, from greater distances on land.

Its eye-catchiness will divert from every coastal scene on the western Bass Strait coastline. The diminutive Nut at Stanley is 143 metres high. With the wind farm on Robbins Island, the Nut will be left the 201st highest coastal structure west of Table Cape (180 metres) if you only consider the towers.

Tasmania already has more than enough electricity to meet its own needs. So the Robbins Island power output is to be exported to the mainland via a new submarine cable.

The Hammond family has owned Robbins Island since 1958, agisting and then farming Wagyu beef cattle. The arrangement between the Hammonds and UPC is not known.

UPC is a multinational corporation which claims that “We are a leading renewable energy developer in the Asia Pacific region with over 20 years of global experience and a proven history of being a successful early entrant in new markets and tackling complex projects”.

UPC has 73 solar and wind projects in 12 countries. Robbins Island would produce 400-1000MW.

The company also says that “UPC-formed companies have developed more than 4500MW operating wind and solar projects and secured more than US$8.4 billion of project debt and equity. UPC now owns operating projects in China, the Philippines and Indonesia and is developing a project pipeline of more than 6GW in Australia, China, the Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam, India, Taiwan, Korea and Tunisia.” Perhaps that means the Robbins Island power will cross the equator.

The world needs energy efficiency and renewable energy to replace fossil fuels, and fast. However, as with the Harmony Hotel proposal, this Robbins Island wind farm is an aileron too far.

Firstly, the Tasmanian public, including the people of the North-West of the island, has not been properly informed of the private deals, or public impacts or cost-benefit analyses (economic, social, cultural and environmental) of this, one of the biggest wind farm projects on Earth.

Here are a few concerns. Besides the impact on the coastal scenery, wind turbines kill birds. Wedge-tailed eagle and white-bellied sea eagles nest and hunt on the island. Swift parrots and orange-bellied parrots traverse the island on their migrations.

Multiple species of international migratory, endangered and critically endangered shorebirds use the wetlands for six months of the year: Australian fairy tern, fork-tailed swift, little tern, white-throated needletail, ruddy turnstone, sharp-tailed sandpiper, sanderling, red knot, curlew sandpiper, red-necked stint, great knot, double-banded plover, greater sand plover, lesser sand plover, Latham’s snipe, bar-tailed godwit, eastern curlew, whimbrel, golden plover, grey plover, grey-tailed tattler, common greenshank, terek sandpiper, hooded plover. For which of these species will the wind farm be the thousandth cut?

The transmission lines are planned to cut through wild and scenic Tasmania, including the northeast Tarkine forests and (until local outrage led to a sudden change) the Leven Canyon, en route to Sheffield and then the new export cable beneath Bass Strait. Why not use the more direct, much less environmentally destructive route aligning the Bass Highway? Better still, in the name of private enterprise, why not UPC build its own cable under the Strait from Robbins Island straight to wherever?

Tasmanians have a right to know much more about the Robbins Island development. It is a huge resource extraction venture which will be lighting up no Tasmanian homes. Beyond the indisputable environmental losses, what is the guaranteed money this giant venture is returning to the state of Tasmania as against UPC’s foreign stakeholders?

– Bob Brown

Former Tasmanian senator and Greens leader, Dr Bob Brown, is the founder of the Bob Brown Foundation.

Showing 19 reactions

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Christopher Nagle
    commented 2019-08-01 15:43:05 +1000
    It seems to me that Bob wants his environmental cake and eat it as well.

    Sure, there will be some bird strike casualties with any wind farm, which NIMBY objectors have long pointed to as a way of obstructing wind projects everywhere, but if we want wind, along with solar and other renewables to take us towards 100% of the grid, we are going to need a lot of this type of renewables energy scale.

    And the fundamental point is that any wind energy environmental downsides are insignificant in comparison with what they are replacing.

    More, the urgency with which we have to get this energy replacement suite into place means we cannot afford the sort of prevarication that Bob seems to want to indulge in.
  • David Bowskill
    followed this page 2019-07-26 20:14:47 +1000
  • Brian O'Byrne
    followed this page 2019-07-23 16:38:19 +1000
  • Pat Mackle
    followed this page 2019-07-23 13:54:02 +1000
  • Jennifer Webb
    followed this page 2019-07-23 11:37:36 +1000
  • Sharon Miller
    followed this page 2019-07-21 07:45:50 +1000
  • Ted Mead
    followed this page 2019-07-20 09:26:48 +1000
  • Janet Medley
    followed this page 2019-07-19 16:19:20 +1000
  • Mary Steed
    followed this page 2019-07-19 10:13:48 +1000
  • Anne Foale
    followed this page 2019-07-19 09:32:07 +1000
  • Marie Morris
    followed this page 2019-07-19 09:09:01 +1000
  • Sue Travers
    followed this page 2019-07-18 22:24:28 +1000
  • Colin Smith
    followed this page 2019-07-18 22:02:03 +1000
  • Bronwyn Simons
    followed this page 2019-07-18 21:19:44 +1000
  • Liz Lokhorst
    followed this page 2019-07-18 21:13:50 +1000
  • Peter McGinty
    commented 2019-07-16 20:47:51 +1000
    Dear Dr Brown

    At least you have the courage to make your views public. You made these comments knowing that you would be ridiculed for hypocrisy.

    What did the public hear from the Australian Greens…. environmentally friendly crickets. Not a peep on a topic that had been splashed all over the media. The Australian Greens were too busy today grandstanding their proposal to increase the NewStart increase, which had zero chance of being successful.

    I may not agree with everything that you say, but I respect your opinion. I have always valued your contribution to Australian politics and your commitment to the environment. Most of all, I admire your courage to voice your opinion when your know that you will be slammed in the media.

    Thank you.

  • Matthew Wright
    commented 2019-07-15 18:13:15 +1000
    The problems is Tasmania needs to think globally while acting locally which means they need to look at the energy intensity of Tasmanians/ Just meeting today’s electricity needs in the Apple Isle is absolutely nowhere close to the per capita embodied energy built into Tasmania’s population. Tasmania needs enough electricity to eliminate all fossil fuel imports and with petrol tankers arriving weekly and gas being burnt from Bass Strait Tasmania is a long way off.
  • 🎃 Mushing Watermelon🍉
    commented 2019-07-15 15:03:48 +1000
    Read the letter

    “Tasmania already has more than enough electricity to meet its own needs. So the Robbins Island power output is to be exported to the mainland via a new submarine cable.”

    Maybe, we should start looking at our excessive use of artificial electricity.
  • Peter McGinty
    commented 2019-07-15 10:00:01 +1000
    Dear Dr Brown,

    What is your solution for making a sustainable, sufficient and stable supply of electricity for Tasmania and the mainland?